Plagiarism is more
prevalent in education, influenced by cultural difference and its ambiguous
boundary. For example, Elizabeth Redden, in his article “cheating across
cultures”, addresses the issue that 34 Duke university school students were
found collaborating on a take-home test. Geenblatt, as cited by Redden, argues
that one of the reasons of this problem is that Asian students cannot fit in
the western styles of quoting and are regard plagiarism as normal, due to the
cultural difference. For my own experience, our teachers have never told us the
definition of plagiarism and how to avoid it. We can use others’ academic paper
without quoting and download the music whatever we like. Nevertheless, these
are illegal behaviors in USA, which is extremely different from Chinese
situation. Another key point is the language barrier. Students and even honor
code students maybe get pressure and lazy on doing homework. Consequently, they
find people or some website to help them to write essay, as included by G.
Thomas Courser and Dan Berrett in their articles “Dear plagiarist” and “An
academic ghostwriter, the ‘shadow scholar’, comes clean”. Moreover, freshman
have trouble to define the boundary of cheating, which can also result in
plagiarism. Marita, mentioned by Mike Rose, in his article “Lives on the
boundary”, was accused by copying others work, punished by teacher. She
acknowledged some sources, not quoting all the sentences perfectly, but
endeavoring to finish assignment well, which is unconscious plagiarism. Besides
this issue, cartoonists are easier to make mistakes in plagiarism, since the
symbols and pictures are common, which lead them to have unique ideas. All
these phenomena result from the ignorance of importance of plagiarism. Patricia
McGuire, in her article “the culture of deceit”, criticizes the problem of
cheating spreading in society. She points out that many children are not regard
plagiarism as a big deal and find excuses for their fault. Above all, we need
to explore methods to avoid plagiarism to insure the quality of education.
Good job of summarizing Lives on the Boundary, but Dear Plagiarist needs more explanation.
ReplyDelete