Saturday, October 20, 2012
Blog 7 - Issue Paragraph-Yuhang Yi
There are several
perspectives toward plagiarism since it has become a hot topic in the world.
Plagiarism could be affect by culture, educational background or some other complex
factors. However, Stanley Fish, a college professor claims that plagiarism should
only easily be viewed a rule of game. It is partially right that plagiarism is
like the rule of a sport game such as the example he gives in his article ”
Plagiarism Is Not a Big Moral Deal”. It says golf has a strict rule;
nevertheless, no matter how serious it is, it’s still a game. A game is used
for playing. Thus, if the requirement is only following the rule, then here
comes many ways to play the game. There is a group of people called ghostwriters.
They are educated and trained writers who could write a essay under those
academic rules. Dave Tomar, a former academic ghostwriter, cited by Dan Berrett
in his article “An Academic Ghostwriter, the
'Shadow Scholar,' Comes Clean”
acknowledges that he had written for a number of college students including
undergraduate, master and even doctor. How could this profession come out? Why
those high educated people keep hiring ghostwriters? And why do people view
that as inappropriate? The reason is that plagiarism could not be viewed as a
simple problem solved by the strict rule; it is an issue having a higher level
which is a moral deal.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Good discussion of both sides.
ReplyDelete